but i think i really wanted to like it more than i actually did because of all the hype. And tonight, I say no. Creating notes and highlights requires a free LitCharts account. Because she hadnt been willing to let the night end. And as she traverses across France and eventually America, centuries pass and Addie cant have the intimacy that develops over time. But as the 300-year anniversary of Addies deal with Luc gets closer, Addie becomes increasingly terrified that he will reappear and ruin everything shes built with Henry. The beginnings of something. Soon, a god that resembles the handsome stranger Addie has fantasized about since adolescence answers Addies prayers and agrees to grant Addie the freedom and more time that she desiresif she promises to surrender her soul to him once she grows bored or tired of her immortality. Once he appears, chapters from his point of view alternate with Addies, but as the title indicates, this is not really his story, but hers. The level of navel gazing is 110% and really lays it on thick - it feels like watching an artsy indie film with sentimental white hipsters and a splash of magic, albeit written elegantly! im not justifying his behavior and he is by no means a good character. Her parents forget they had a daughter. You'll be able to access your notes and highlights, make requests, and get updates on new titles. That doesnt mean it doesnt change us. After she takes a book from his shop. Luc visited him and granted his wish: whenever someone would see him, they would see what they desire the most. Addie enters The Last Word, the bookstore where Henry works, and tries to steal a book (stealing is easy for her, since nobody recognizes her once a door shuts between them). Schwab's Novel 'Invisible Life of Addie LaRue' Getting Film Adaptation at eOne (EXCLUSIVE)", "Augustine Frizzell to Direct 'The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue' Film Adaptation for eOne (EXCLUSIVE)", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=The_Invisible_Life_of_Addie_LaRue&oldid=1141426050, Short description is different from Wikidata, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 25 February 2023, at 00:44. Schwab published in 2020. He nods at the piano, and she wants him to say something like, I didnt know you could play, but instead Toby says, Youre really good, and she isits amazing what you can learn when you have the time.Thanks, she says, running her fingertips across the keys.Toby is restless now, escaping to the kitchen. I am a lifelong New Yorker, and the way she writes my city makes me see it in an entirely new, wondrous light. Life is long when youre lonely, and impossibly short when youre not. Girl falls in love with the only boy who seems to understand her; the obstacles between them must be, by the end, either overcome or acknowledged as insurmountable. idk i think luc is a more dynamic character than you are giving him credit for. WebIs Addie LaRue sad? . When you finish, though, you realize that no matter what you anticipated or thought that shape was in the distance, its different up close but its the only ending that feels right. He tells her that he intentionally allowed Henry and Addie to meet. He publishes a novel about her life and we learn that she is with Luc in London and she plans on doing everything in her power to make Luc not want to be with her so she can finally be free of him. on Worship in Piano: Caleb Trezises Senior Recital. Addie realizes that her deal with the old god (whom Addie will later name Luc) has a cruel, unexpected caveat. Henry and Addie arent equal partners, exactly, but theyre partners in a meaningful, resonant way. However, the deal comes at a great cost: Everybody who meets Addie immediately forgets her. Because the thing is, humans forget everything. but i think i really wanted to like it more than i actually did because of all the hype. Once upon a time a young woman was in a desperate place and made a desperate choice for freedom. Schwab is simply one of the most skilled writers working in her genre. WebThe novel ends with Addie holding and reading the book with Luc by her side. "The Nerd Daily[An] enthralling romantic adventure.Business Insider"A career triumphHer propulsive, lyric prose is here, her morally complex, entrancing characters, her unique shape of magic, all wrought within this entirely fresh premise that will no doubt become a long-lasting favoriteAddie defies genre, blending romance and history, fantasy and monstrosity, cresting through peaks of time, centered on a young (and also, technically very old) woman with both less and more agency than anyone aliveromantic, ambitious, and defiantly, deliberately hopeful. The sounds die in her throat.Her fingers fall away from the glass and she turns, surveying the living room.Toby is a musician, and the signs of his art are everywhere.In the instruments that lean against the walls. i think that the story was actually pretty good but it wasnt what it was advertised as. It just tells a gorgeous, immersive story, gripping the reader with a tale of disappointment and triumph, damage and healing, fear and wonder, and above all, memory. I may announce you one of top ten best books of the year. My default answer was No, this is a rom-com, give it a happy ending, the universe commands it. i see that. What it can be, what it saves, what it distorts, what it inspires, and what it cant capture. Thanks for the shoutout! Of cruelty, and war, but also art and invention.". Until one day, in a second hand bookshop in Manhattan, Addie meets someone who remembers her. Wasnt ready to let go.She lifts the mug, inhales the scent as memories waft up to meet it.A park in London. When we see that our favorite characters understand this too, something inside of us sighs, Ah. Addie hates Luc. Meanwhile, she herself cannot forget. But every choice brings its consequences. The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue and the Importance of a Real Ending. But every choice brings its consequences. Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. Addie ultimately breaks off the relationship in 1984, believing that Lucs love is merely another calculated effort to manipulate her into surrendering her soul to him. WebThe Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is a historical fantasy novel by the American author V.E. The moment a person leaves the room, turns away, wakes beside her, she becomes a stranger, again and again. Schwab evokes Hades and Persephone, Orpheus and Eurydice, Sisyphus and more to craft a new mythology all her own. But here and there, another handthe flowers hes started keeping on the kitchen sill, though he cant remember when the habit started. When everything feels either tragically impermanent or interminably cruel, what we have is the beauty we can find in the world and those we share it with, and it, be found. It lets in storms. "[7], In November 2021, it was announced that eOne will produce a film adaptation of the novel. WebAddie, the novels 23-year-old protagonist, is fiercely independentshe longs for a life of adventure outside of Villon-sur-Sarthe, her small French village. They enjoy just being together, and they drive upstate to look at the stars. In a sunlit city day, in the sailboats set out to the horizon. Her propulsive, lyric prose is here, her morally complex, entrancing characters, her unique shape of magic, all wrought within this entirely fresh premise that will no doubt become a long-lasting favorite. If you find yourself longing for a simple story that will sprout and grow in your heart, a book that examines a life among many, and one that reawakens wonder even in the midst of the bittersweet, Addie LaRue invites you to read about her invisible life. When a book traps your soul from beginning to end and beyond, keeping hold of a string to your heart even as you leave it behind, Welcome back students. Addie as an echo, a shadow, a myth, a muse. Suddenly thrust back into a real, normal life, Addie realises she can't escape her fate forever. You can help us out by revising, improving and updating this section. ", "Because time is cruel to all, and crueler still to artists. The woman wrote a good bookwhether its magical realism or historical fiction or bildungsroman. I am a lifelong New Yorker, and the way she writes my city makes me see it in an entirely new, wondrous light. The Invisible Life of Addie Larue will enchant readers as deeply as its heroines Faustian bargain; you will find yourself in quick turns both aching with heartbreak, and gleefully crowing at the truly delicious, wicked cleverness in store. Naomi Novik, Nebula and Locus Award-winning author of Spinning Silver Required fields are marked *. Out now: THE ARCTIC FURY. At first, the deal was great. An eternity of flitting from one place to another, never feeling quite at home anywhere, and from one person to another, leaving behind only the phantom feel of her touch, and the faint memory of seven freckles dotting her cheeks, like a scattering of stars. At the same time, shes attracted to him. It was my first beatboxing performance! The dark, entrancing figure who negotiates the bargaintaking the good-looking, masculine form of one of Adelines own drawings, and later, given the name Luc by Addie herselfblesses and curses her with a kind of immortality: she will live as she wants, freely, until she tires of life, only no one she meets will remember her. WebAddie realizes that her deal with the old god (whom Addie will later name Luc) has a cruel, unexpected caveat. And so much of who we are is tied to who we are to others. He did play it for her. The more time Henry and Addie spend together, the deeper their feelings for each other become. By giving us someone who for so long cant leave a mark, Schwab makes it sparklingly clear how much of an impact we can have, every day, and how wild and powerful that is. Not only this, but Addie can say her name in front of Henry and tell him her story. Addie longs to be like Estele, an eccentric old woman who prays to read analysis of Adeline Addie LaRue. i dont know the ending just feels like were back at a beginning and the game starts again between these two toxic lovers. And that matters. It has been 300 years since anyone has remembered her face longer than a few hours. she shows us our world, tells us theres curses and magic written within its very making, that theres meaning to our myths and our gods, and I believe her. WebThe affair ends once Addie suspects that Lucs feelings are yet another attempt to get her to surrender her soul; indeed, Lucs interest in Addie is born of his desire to possess her, and he repeatedly fails to understand her. That this is good, this is different, this is something. In retaliation, Luc burns down the house in New Orleans theyve been living in together. A Story You Will Never Forget. Fans of fantasy, science fiction, horror, alt history, and more can all find a home with us. This is a Young Adult book that heavily leans on the Adult part of the genre. Luc has given Addie the freedom and immortality she asked for, but the tradeoff is that she must live an invisible life in which everyone she meets (and even people shes known her entire life) forget her immediately. A vibrant novel that is all about living life to the fullest, The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue will be available from Tor Books on October 6, 2020. Girl falls in love with the only boy who seems to understand her; the obstacles between them must be, by the end, either overcome or acknowledged as insurmountable. Whoops! When Addie comes to, its light outside; she no longer hears the wedding party calling after her. Yet in Schwabs talented, inventive hands, there turns out to be a third way. However, the deal comes at a great cost: Everybody who meets Addie immediately forgets her. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Luc confessed to her that he always loved her, but Addie secretly plans to make his existence miserable at her side, so that he eventually ends their pact and takes her soul. Your email address will not be published. That no life is easy or wholly good. [This novel] isironicallyunforgettable. Hugo Award winner Alix E. Harrow, author of The Ten Thousand Doors of JanuaryThe Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is the kind of book you encounter only once in a lifetime. Schwab is known for tortured characters who seem dark and are the antagonist but there is always more to them. Update this section! Luc returns at irregular intervals to torment her, but she resists the urge to give up and surrender her soul even when times grow desperate. Addie, one of the author's most morally complex and riveting creations, embarks on adventures both grand and lowly, as she travels, ghostlike, through the centuries." Maya Gittelman is a queer Pilipinx-Jewish diaspora writer and poet. Luc rejected the ring in the woods that night, explaining that he needed something far more valuableAddies soulto seal the deal. Literally speechless, wordless, expressionless, blinking, sighing, awed, adored, fell hard, truly loved! She was to be a wife and mother, all her curiosities hewn away until she was only a core, and even that wasnt to be her own. Addie agrees, then she sinks into the darkness. WebBittersweet Ending: Addie will be remembered forever after a great novel is made about her, and Henry is allowed to live. FICTIONThe Invisible Life of Addie LaRueBy V. E. SchwabTor BooksPublished October 6th, 2020. And when she agrees to come, his smile is dazzling. If you already know Schwab for her previous work, reading this stand-alone will feel both familiar and new; if this is the first novel of hers youve read, no context is required. Addie has hope that she can manipulate Luc to let her go and finally have peace. Im not that kind of guy.She smiles. A rose by any other name and all that. A tea room in Edinburgh.The past drawn like a silk sheet over the present.Its a cold morning in New York, the windows fogged with frost, so she pulls a blanket from the back of the couch and wraps it around her shoulders. Here, as the world feels like its ending for so many of us, when we have to be apart from our loved ones more than ever before, when we dont know what the future looks like, when we dont know how much worse it will get or how much time we have left, Addie reminds us that it is worth it, to live. Addie decides never to summon Luc, not wanting to give him the satisfaction of seeing her weak and desperate. As much as we want to escape sometimes and we often do, into our screens, our work, our shows the bittersweet ending is a gentle transition back from the realm of the imaginary. if you want to hear my thoughts on this book, i talk about it in detail in this video: okay wow i loved this book. ", "His heart has a draft. In exchange, Luc will let Henry live. Hidden barbs designed to sting. You dont need to have read Schwabs other books to enjoy Addieits a great introduction to her workbut the many fans who go into this book with expectations will find them thoroughly met and more. She just wanted to explore the wonders of the world, to experience the possibilities outside her town. But those books have already been written. And books. Macallister). Info on the film adaptation with Schwab as screenwriter. Unbeknownst to Henry, Addie sneaks out to meet with Luc shortly before the day Henry is scheduled to die. Should have been out of sight as well as out of mind, but theres always that nagging hope that this time, it will be different, that this time, they will remember.I remember, says the darkness in her ear.She shakes her head, forcing the voice away.Wheres the rush? asks Toby. I dont find the point of discussing genres as a jumping off point for evaluating the novel. Alone in the world, Addie has no choice but to confront him, to understand him, maybe to beat him. She hadnt wanted to be beholden to the expectations of her era, the rules inscribed on the shape of her body. The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. In lesser hands the story might become predictable. There is no such thing as life or love without an ending. Everyone wants or loves Henry. Schwab is simply one of the most skilled writers working in her genre. WebAddie, the novels 23-year-old protagonist, is fiercely independentshe longs for a life of adventure outside of Villon-sur-Sarthe, her small French village. Nothing concrete, of course, but inspiration rarely is.Tobys got the guitar up now, balanced on one knee, and he follows her lead, murmuring to himself. Their relationship sweetens through the centuries, but Addies suspicions about his motivation sour their attachment until the elastic tension between them stretches to a breaking point. Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1699 titles we cover. The central love story is m/f, but both leads, though their sexualities arent labeled, are queer, bi, or pan, and their relationship is not a straight one. You should come. But its not that her endings are shocking or nonsensical. What is a person, if not the marks they leave behind? She hasnt seen Luc since their breakup in 1984. [3], Caitlyn Paxson at NPR praised the novel, particularly the attention to art: "her seven signature frecklesshe has attempted to imprint herself in an artist's mindfleeting impressions of a forgotten immortal. And so Addie embarks on a journey that feels like a curse. but nothing is completely evil or completely pure/kind. just because a being isnt human, does not make them incapable of feelings??? I dont want to say this book exemplifies a writer at the top of her game, because anyone whos read Schwabs other books knows, she just hits peak after peak. Nevertheless, Addie is determined not to give in to Luc, who is convinced from the start that Addies loneliness will eat away at her until she begs him to take her soul and put her out of her misery. This is the grass between the nettles. Maya Gittelman is a queer Pilipinx-Jewish diaspora writer and poet. Love this very much, really captures what d&d truly is, not the idea that outsider judge it for without playing. i think he is lonely just as Addie is and forgotten to some extent like she is. When it becomes the movie, then we ll know how well it lent itself to the big screen. Hes already setting the coffee aside, reaching for a pencil and a notepad off the nearest table. Schwab captured lightning in a bottlejust like Faust, only its a female protagonist. WebThe Invisible Life of Addie LaRue V.E. AdBut she only gets as far as that before the letters dissolve. When everything feels either tragically impermanent or interminably cruel, what we have is the beauty we can find in the world and those we share it with, and it can be found. Luc, therefore, becomes the only constant in her life, and she comes to look forward to his visits and misses him when hes not around. This book feels timeless, in that exquisite way Schwab books very often do, especially with its roots in eighteenth-century France and its branches spanning up into a very recent New York City. The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is available from Tor Books. Schwab evokes Hades and Persephone, Orpheus and Eurydice, Sisyphus and more to craft a new mythology all her own. The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is available from Tor Books. What did you think of the way Schwab talks about ideas and how they last longer than legacies? It has been 300 years since anyone has remembered her face longer than a few hours. Refine any search. Once its finally revealed why Henry remembers Addie when no one else does, the reason makes sense; Schwab is an author who understands the importance of both subverting and satisfying reader expectations. Estele, an eccentric old woman from Addies village, taught Addie how to pray to the old gods. There are seldom plans of ours that fly without turbulence. I dont want to say this book exemplifies a writer at the top of her game, because anyone whos read Schwabs other books knows, she just hits peak after peak. Schwab Summary A Life No One Will Remember. The things that last, even when memories dont.Toby is a slow riser, so Addie makes herself teahe doesnt drink it, but its already there, in his cupboard, a tin of loose Ceylon, and a box of silk pouches. WebThe Invisible Life of Addie LaRue V.E. Schwab 4.21 798,889 ratings105,854 reviews Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Best Fantasy (2020) France, 1714: in a moment of desperation, a young woman makes a Faustian bargain to live forever and is cursed to be forgotten by everyone she meets. It has been 300 years since anyone has remembered her face longer than a few hours. I am the darkness between stars, and the roots beneath the earth. [6], Megan Kallstrom of Slate noted the story's careful attention to detail, ending her review by saying: "Much like the seven freckles that sprinkle Addies face, we create our own constellations, and as we live through these darkened days, I feel brighter for having added Addie to mine. However, Henry will still die naturally, Luc will still get Henry's soul, Addie never breaks her own curse, and Addie agrees to But that doesnt mean it doesnt matter. I've never met you before but I'd love to talk, After four years of our precious Katrina leaving us, the pain is still deep. on Dungeons & Dragons: Heresy or Catharsis? But its also almost viciously timely. And in the end, thats the only thing thats important to remember. She accidentally catches the attention of a god of the night, who she would later name Luc, who promises her the time she wants with the caveat being nobody will ever remember her after one encounter. But Lucs plan backfires. Teachers and parents! Worse, because ghosts are memories and Addie passes through the world without leaving even those. Coffee? he asks, shuffling through the cupboards.I found tea.She starts to play a different song. France, 1714: in a moment of desperation, a young woman makes a Faustian bargain to live foreverand is cursed to be forgotten by everyone she meets. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. Your email address will not be published. But everything changes when, after nearly 300 years, Addie stumbles across a young man in a hidden bookstore and he remembers her name.Also by V. E. SchwabShades of MagicA Darker Shade of Magic A Gathering of Shadows A Conjuring of LightVillainsVicious Vengeful, Organize a Book Club Nothing intricate, just a strain of notes. The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is romantic, ambitious, and defiantly, deliberately hopeful. ", "Spells are for the witches, and witches are too often burned. In this way, Addie leaves a lasting impression on peoples lives, even as the physical memory of her erodes. Maya Gittelman is a queer Pilipinx-Jewish diaspora writer and poet. The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is a fantasy novel by the American author V. E. Schwab. "Book Riot, 25 Must Read New Fantasy BooksA remarkable, genre-defying epic of a woman fighting to thrive in a world that denies her existence.stunning.Shelf Awareness for Readers"When I first finished Addie LaRue, I sat back with a deep sense of wonder. However, Henry will still die naturally, Luc will still get Henry's soul, Addie never breaks her own curse, and Addie agrees to The back cover copy from the publisher describes the book as genre-defying, but what is there to defy? But Addie refuses to give in to loneliness and misery. Just finished this book eaaaaaaaarly this morning and cant stop twisting and turning over it. NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLERUSA TODAY BESTSELLER NATIONAL INDIE BESTSELLERTHE WASHINGTON POST NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLERUSA TODAY BESTSELLER NATIONAL INDIE BESTSELLERTHE WASHINGTON POST BESTSELLERRecommended by Entertainment Weekly, Real Simple, NPR, Slate, and Oprah Magazine #1 Library Reads PickOctober 2020#1 Indie Next PickOctober 2020BOOK OF THE YEAR (2020) FINALISTBook of The Month ClubA Best Of Book From: Oprah Mag * CNN * Amazon * Amazon Editors * NPR * Goodreads * Bustle * PopSugar * BuzzFeed * Barnes & Noble * Kirkus Reviews * Lambda Literary * Nerdette * The Nerd Daily * Polygon * Library Reads * io9 * Smart Bitches Trashy Books * LiteraryHub * Medium * BookBub * The Mary Sue * Chicago Tribune * NY Daily News * SyFy Wire * Powells.com * Bookish * Book Riot * Library Reads Voter Favorite *In the vein of The Time Travelers Wife and Life After Life, The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is New York Times bestselling author V. E. Schwabs genre-defying tour de force. Addie defies genre, blending romance and history, fantasy and monstrosity, cresting through peaks of time, centered on a young (and also, technically very old) woman with both less and more agency than anyone alive. She makes Henry promise to remember her, and then she vanishes. Get help and learn more about the design. There is certainly a time for it. Henry is warm-hearted and kind, prone to depression, and just as drawn to Addie as she is to him. The ending of The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue was so disappointing!! Here, as the world feels like its ending for so many of us, when we have to be apart from our loved ones more than ever before, when we dont know what the future looks like, when we dont know how much worse it will get or how much time we have leftAddie reminds us that it is worth it, to live. WebAt the novel's end, Addie sacrifices herself to Luc, agreeing to be his so long as he wants her at his side. Girl falls in love with the only boy who seems to understand her; the obstacles between them must be, by the end, either overcome or acknowledged as insurmountable. He takes Addie out for a romantic evening to try to win her back, but shes already made up her mind. That is where they met for the first time, and the fifth, and the ninth. He fumbles for the right words, and then gives up, starts again. Once upon a time a young woman was in a desperate place and made a desperate choice for freedom. Press J to jump to the feed. Schwab's 'The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue', "Hardcover Fiction Books - Best Sellers - Books - June 20, 2021 - The New York Times", "In The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue, Isolation Is a Curse. Life is long when youre lonely, and impossibly short when youre not. Born in a small French village in 1691, Adeline LaRue makes a bargain with the gods that answer after dark to escape an unwanted marriage. She has learned to step between the thorny weeds, but there are some cuts that cannot be avoideda memory, a photograph, a name.In the last month, she has been Claire, Zoe, Michellebut two nights ago, when she was Elle, and they were closing down a late-night caf after one of his gigs, Toby said that he was in love with a girl named Jesshe simply hadnt met her yet.So now, she is Jess.Toby begins to stir, and she feels the old familiar ache in her chest as he stretches, rolls toward herbut doesnt wake, not yet. dont get me wrong i thought the writing was beautiful and i felt so many emotions reading this book. When dreamers were most prone to bad ideas, and wanderers were likely to get lost.Addie has always been predisposed to both.It makes sense then, that she was born on the 10th of March, right along the ragged seam, though it has been so long since Addie felt like celebrating.Copyright 2020 by Victoria Schwab. Complete your free account to access notes and highlights, The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue Summary. Heres a seemingly contradictory truth to the previous one: I have seen many early 90s chick flicks. I feel like you read the ending very differently than I did. Here. (including. That, in fact, is a sort of freedom in and of itself. In loved ones, imperfect as we all are. What it can be, what it saves, what it distorts, what it inspires, and what it cant capture. Are you Suffering from the Almost Spring Break Blues? She renders our world so clearly we recognize it, and then fills in the corners, the cracks, so that it feels as if the very air around us brims with her own specific magic, and we might just see it if we know where to look. July 29, 1714 is the day that 23-year-old Addie LaRue is supposed to marry Roger, a widower from her small French village of Villon-sur-Sarthe. He uses these stories to create his first novel, The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue. LitCharts Teacher Editions. But Henry doesnt share with Addie the most troubling aspect of his curse: that its only good for one year. In 1952, when Addie is living in the U.S., she and Luc begin a decades-long romance. Everyone wants to date him, and everyone thinks hes charming, smart, and funny. I CANNOT STOP CRYING. Hes an abusive, evil creature who doesnt comprehend true love. "Stories come in so many forms: in charcoal, and in song, in paintings, poems, films. Please don't hate, ok? It begins in the early 1700s, following Addie as a young woman burdened by a forced marriage and praying to the gods for her freedom. Because vision weakens, and voices wither, and talent fades. " But despite these hardships, Addie maintains her open, curious attitude toward the world, and each day that shes able to taste, learn, and experience something new reminds her that those hardships are worth it. Alone in the world, Addie has no choice but to confront him, to understand him, maybe to beat him. July 29, 1714. Details long memorized.His name is Toby.Last night, she told him hers was Jess. The central love story is m/f, but both leads, though their sexualities arent labeled, are queer, bi, or pan, and their relationship is not a straight one. She lied, but only because she cant say her real nameone of the vicious little details tucked like nettles in the grass. A superstition. Alone in the world, Addie has no choice but to confront him, to understand him, maybe to beat him. He publishes a novel about her life and we learn that she is with Luc in London and she plans on doing everything in her power to make Luc not want to be with her so she can finally be free of him. i agree to some extent i guess it reinforces the nature of their push and pull relationship. Its okay, she says, if you dont remember.Toby blushes, and nudges Toby-the-cat out of the way as he sinks onto the couch cushions.